Keep Your Deck Fresh: The Best Grill Mats of 2018

Grilling outside on your deck is one of the best parts of your home, but without the right care and attention, over time, grilling can destroy your deck with grease and sauce stains.

A deck grill mat is a crucial component of any grill station to help lengthen the life of your deck and maintain its cleanliness.

There are many different types of decks and grills, so making sure you find the right deck grill mat for your needs is essential.

In this article, we’re going to examine what a Deck Grill Mat is, what makes a good deck grill mat, and the pros and cons of owning one.

Comparison Chart of the Best Grill Mats for Your Deck

What is a Deck Grill Mat?

A Deck Grill Mat is a tool used to protect your deck from grease, sauce, or other liquids that can splatter on your deck while grilling.

The mat goes on the deck below the grill and, depending on which mat you purchase, will protect your deck one of two ways.

The first type is made from absorbent material that will trap grease; the second type is made from a repellent material that allows grease to sit on top for later clean-up.

Both low-cost and high-cost grills can cause damage to your deck, making a Deck Grill Mat an important part of your set-up.

What is a Deck Grill Mat Best For?

The number one best use for a Deck Grill Mat is to protect the area directly under your grill from grease splatter.

Grease stains are very tough to remove, and can end up being a larger financial burden than the initial cost of a Deck Grill Mat.

Even if you’re not using your grill year round, there are other uses for your mat.

Grill mats can also be used in car maintenance. Just place your mat under your car to catch any oil or grease dripping down.

You can also bring your mat inside to protect your kitchen floors when making larger meals, for example, when deep-frying thanksgiving turkey.

A grill mat can provide protection from all types of grease splatter, and some can be used on a variety of different surfaces without sticking.

Aspects of the Best Grill Mats

When looking at grill mats, a flexible material is going to give you the most versatile use; it will be easier to transport and set up. An absorbent material will be safer for deck use.

Repellent mats allow the grease to sit on top to be wiped down later, which could be hazardous for any children or pets running around.

It’s best to opt for a mat that’s slightly larger than what you might think you need. This will ensure that your deck is protected from any and all splatters that come off your grill.

Mats that resist tearing and curling under heat exposure are the best option for long-term use.

Willy's Top Picks - Best Grill Mats For Decks

Review of the Best Grill Mats for Decks

Now that we've covered what a grill mat is and some qualities of a top of the line model, we're going to take a look at some of our top picks.

We're going to review each product's main features, then dive into their pros and cons. Let's get started!

1. Premium Grill Mat by Montana Grilling Gear

This large, absorbent mat can work for both gas and electric grills. It works by soaking up grease splatters and preventing them from leaking through the other side.

Clean up is easy: simply spray with the hose or rinse with water. This mat lays flat and won’t curl up; this will keep your deck protected and maintain an aesthetically pleasing environment.

Pros

  • Leak proof
  • Large 30” x 48”
  • Withstands light rain
  • Satisfaction guarantee
  • Non-skidding: will stay put
  • Protects wood, brick, and concrete

Cons

  • Only available in one size
  • Not suitable for charcoal grills
  • Not a true black – dark grayish

Bottom Line

If you have a gas or electric grill and want a lightweight layer of protection, this mat will work great for you. Be sure to find another option if you have a charcoal grill, and if you live in an area with heavy rainfall, it may become worn.

2. Drymate Gas Grill Mat

This fabric, absorbent mat is eco-friendly and USA made. It has a waterproof backing that prevents grease from leaking through, and will work on your deck, patio, or other outdoor surfaces. Its flexible, lightweight fabric makes it easy to transport and store.

Pros

  • Light, but durable
  • Safe for kids and pets
  • Phthalate and BPA free
  • Extra large size 30” x 58”
  • Water-proof/slip-proof backing

Cons

  • Holds water in rainfall
  • Needs to be weighed down
  • Not suitable for charcoal grill
  • If left out in rain, may stain surfaces

Bottom Line 

An extra large, yet still lightweight option for your deck. The waterproof backing will prevent grease from leaking out, but the super absorbent top will hold water if left out in the rain. Great for gas or electric grills, but not charcoal.

3. The Gas Grill Splatter Mat

This reversible absorbent mat can protect your outdoor surface from grease splatters, without anything leaking through.

The fabric is composed of non-woven fibers that will not stick to your composite decking. It comes in two lengths, 48” x 30” and 60” x 30”, to fit your specific grilling needs.

Pros

  • Extra long
  • 100% recyclable materials
  • Holds up to 5 times its weight
  • Internal barrier prevents leaks, making the mat reversible
  • Works on wood, brick, stone, slate, cement, and composite decking

Cons

  • Slippery
  • Doesn’t feel sturdy
  • May discolor deck if wet
  • Grass clippings etc. stick to it
  • Needs to hang dry after rainfall

Bottom Line

This product is not suited to the elements, but if you’re in an area with very low rainfall, this highly absorbent mat will soak up all splatter that gets on it. It’s environmentally friendly and versatile, but not durable in unpredictable weather.

4. The Original Grill Pad Gray Grill Pad

The Original Grill Pad is designed to work under gas and charcoal grills. Its fiber-cement makeup makes this pad heat and weather resistant, and it’s compatible with composite decking.

The Original Grill Pad requires hand washing, not hose or power washing. At 8 pounds, the pad is heavy enough to stay put on its own.

Pros

  • Heavy
  • Heat resistant
  • Snow/Ice resistant
  • Compatible with charcoal grills
  • Compatible with composite decking

Cons

  • Leaves white residue
  • Smaller than other models
  • Not durable for multiple seasons
  • Cannot clean with power/pressure washer
  • Need at least 24” clearance from mat to grill

Bottom Line

Do not use this product if your grill is less than 24” tall. This is a product will hold up against weather, but cannot be used for fire pits. It comes in many different colors, which allows you to personalize your deck space.

5. Tuffy Reversible BBQ Grill Pad

This multi-use pad will work for your grill, smoker, and fryer. It’s heat resistant, but not suitable to use with a fire pit.

It’s made in the USA and suitable for composite decking. It’s a resistant style mat, meaning it will deflect grease and splatter, as well as rain. It’s composed of recycled rubber and actively contributes toward keeping tires out of our landfills.

Pros

  • USA made
  • Long lasting
  • Easy clean up
  • Recycled materials
  • Mold/mildew resistant
  • Suitable for composite decking

Cons

  • Edges may curl
  • May discolor patio
  • Not suitable for fire pits
  • Not flexible in cold weather
  • Rubbery odor out of the box

Bottom Line

This water resistant pad is perfect if you live in an area with lots of rain, but it may become hard to work with in the colder months. Clean up requires only a quick rinse and a shake, making it incredibly easy to maintain.

Conclusion

With all the different products, what’s most important is determining what your grilling needs are. Knowing what type of grill you have, how large it is, the type of deck, and your preferences is essential when choosing a deck grill mat. 

There will be no denying when you find that mat that’s the best fit for you. Good luck!

Leave a Comment