Complete Buyer’s Guide for the Best George Foreman Grills of 2018

Since its inception in 1994, the George Foreman Grill has grown from a trendy infomercial product, into one of the most recognized culinary brands in America.

Though the brand has recently expanded into the outdoor grilling market, these innovative grills were initially created as a quick, healthy, indoor alternative to stove top, gas, or charcoal grilling.

As the clear cut industry standard for small indoor grills, George Foreman Grills have become almost a necessity to the everyday cook's kitchen arsenal.

In this buyer's guide, we will discuss the versatile nature of George Foreman Grills and dig into just what makes them such a popular choice for so many at home cooks.

We will then transition into some aspects to keep in mind when on the market for one of these wonder products, and finish with a few reviews of some of the best George Foreman models.

Best George Foreman Grills Comparison Chart

What Are George Foreman Grills Best For?

George Foreman Grills offer an interesting take on the classic grill, seeing as it uses a design that cooks food from the top and bottom simultaneously.

This intriguing design can be well utilized for a variety of foods products, though some are much better suited for dual plate cooking than others.

Take for example, the Panini; George Foreman grills are ideal for any sort of hot, grilled sandwich because its two plate design cooks both sides at once, reducing cook time and saving you from the difficulty of flipping a partially grilled sandwich.

In fact, almost any food that needs to be routinely flipped during the cooking process would be a great option for a George Foreman. Ideally, one should stay away from grilling anything complex in these grills.

One would be smart to stick to well contained or singular foods like sandwiches and meats; foods with sauces or any sort of liquid would probably be better off in a pan.

What Sets George Foreman Grills Apart From Other Grills?

George Foreman Grills has made a name for itself as a brand due in large part to the incredibly versatile, innovative, and efficient nature of its products.

Whether you're looking for an indoor alternative to outdoor grilling, quicker cooking, or a slightly healthier diet, George Foreman offers a slew of efficient products that are sure to improve the quality of your cooking experience.

These compact electric grills are a wonderful addition to any kitchen, as they offer a panini press style grilling experience with its double plate design. This remarkably innovative grilling technology cooks food from both the top, and bottom, which drastically cuts cooking time.

 This design is a large part of why so many people swear by the brand; quick, high quality food benefits anyone looking to make the most out of their time. The adjustable hinge that binds the aforementioned cooking plates allows the grill to cook a range of food sizes; be it thin paninis or thick cuts of meat, these grills can handle it.

Further features of these electric grills include a sloped design and non-stick surface, which, together, productively rid the food of excess oil/grease, and subsequently produce a healthier final product.

George Foreman approves of this review (source)

Aspects to Consider When Buying a George Foreman Grill

When sifting through potential George Foreman models on the market, there are a few key aspects to consider. As George Foreman has many different options available, at varying levels of price and quality, there are a number of differences between models.

For the sake of this buyer's guide, we are going to focus on the following four characteristics that especially distinguish a high quality George Foreman Grill from an economical one:

  • Temperature Control
  • Efficiency
  • Usability
  • Cleanability

As is the case with many other culinary appliances, Foreman temperature control serves as an easy way for cooks to monitor and adjust cooking temperature.

Some of the more economic George Foreman grills lack this option, meaning temperature is constant from the illumination of the ready indication light until you unplug it. 

Effectively, this means that models who lack the temperature control option are vastly more limited in terms of their versatility than their counterparts who do.

Efficiency seems like a no-brainer when on the market for nearly any product on the market, culinary or otherwise. Regardless, it is crucial to repeat it here.

The better George Foreman models are going to offer a much stronger final product in a much shorter time than some of the lower echelon grills.

It’s important to consider the temperature that a specific model can reach, how quickly it can cook, and how well it cooks.

The usability of a George Foreman product ties in well to the aforementioned temperature control.

Those products that offer temp control offer a tremendous opportunity for culinary creativity and customization for those at home chefs looking to get a bit more out of their grill, though they can be a bit more difficult to use for inexperienced cooks.

Aside from temp control, a model’s usability can be affected by its warm up time, design (especially with the grease slope), and cleanability. Each of these aspects may individually add to a product’s ease of use, but can pose significant problems if neglected.

As briefly mentioned above, cleanability is yet another major aspect to consider when comparing two different models.

The big distinction with George Foreman grills is whether or not the two plates are removable.

If they are, cleaning is a much more user friendly experience. For those models that do not have removable plates, the design often results in poor cleaning, and consequently rust, or failure of the non-stick coating.

Willy's Top Picks - Best George Foreman Grills

Review of the Best George Foreman Grills

Let's take a closer look at our favorite George Foreman grills. We'll outline why these models are so unique and what recent buyers have to say about their experience. We did our homework here so you don't have to. 

1. George Foreman 4-Serving Grill

As the flagship George Foreman Grill, the 4-serving removable plate grill is one of the best options on the market.

Like many other George Foreman models, its dependable fat-cutting, sloped design produces a much healthier product than traditional grills.

This specific model was designed with small families in mind, as it claims to cook four servings of food simultaneously.

Building on the reputation for speed and efficiency, this model boasts a 35% faster warm-up time than its adversaries, meaning you’ll spend less time waiting too cook, and less time waiting to eat.

In total, customers have reported 10 minutes as the average cook time for a four serving meal, a time which normal grills can’t even dream of approaching.

Pros

  • Cleanable: removable plates make cleaning easy
  • Healthy: 42% fat removal design significantly lowers calories
  • Efficient: 10 minutes cooking time and 35% faster warm-up time
  • Non-Stick: 2x the durable coating guarantees your food won’t stick

Cons

  • Dishwasher: many customers have complained of discoloration or non-stick surface damage
  • Hinge & Temp Control: this product doesn’t offer the floating hinge or temp control, which severely limits cooking options

Bottom Line

The 4-Serving model from George Foreman is a tried and true indoor grill. This grill will make you healthier, quicker meals than any other grill or appliance. As the flagship model, its design is fairly simple, meaning a loss of creativity for the culinary inclined.

Its materials and inability to be dish-washed are certainly a concern, but one must remember that many other products of this nature have similar, if not the same, issues.

All things considered, if you’re going to get a George Foreman, you can’t go wrong here; you just won’t be able to cook a bunch of food at once.

2. George Foreman 6-Serving Grill

George Foreman's 6-serving grill seems to be, at first glance, just a 50% larger version of their classic 4-serving model.

It boasts the same basic design, complete with removable cooking plates for easy clean-up, as well as the fat reducing, angled design of the grilling surface.

However, this grill does, in fact, make some key changes to its materials, as well the intricacies of its design.

The addition of a ceramic coating in lieu of the normal surface results in a non-stick stick surface that's 5x as effective as its predecessor.

Further additions to this model include the floating hinge, which enables the user to adjust the gap between the cooking plates to cook food of various thicknesses, as well as a temperature control switch, giving the user full control over grilling conditions.

Pros

  • Ceramic: a 5x better non-stick surface than traditional George Foreman Grills
  • Size: you can easily fit 6 burgers on to the grilling surface; its size won't let you down
  • Customizable: addition of temperature control and floating hinge give cooks ample room for creativity in the kitchen
  • Classic: the fat-removing design and all the other features that made George Foreman Grills famous are present in this model

Cons

  • Size: large size is great for cooking, rather awkward for storage
  • Temperature Control: customers report variable levels of control over temperature, sometimes it doesn't seem to work at all

Bottom Line

Like any other George Foreman Grill, the 6-serving model will serve as a valuable addition to any kitchen. The larger size of this model is ideal for families or individuals looking to cook a higher volume of food, even if it is difficult to store.

The increase in customization options due the floating hinge is nice, however, the lack of a reliable temperature control significantly affects a cook's options.

As we would suggest with all George Foreman Grills, wash the grilling plates by hand; products who claim to be dishwasher safe are very often not, so it's best to not take the risk.

In short, this product will certainly give you everything you wanted from a George Foreman Grill, though it certainly could be a lot better.

3. George Foreman 9-Serving Grill

The 9-Serving Classic Plate Electric Grill is yet another tried and true George Foreman model which capture exactly what made the brand famous.

The classic George Tough non-stick surface eliminates the need for oil, and subsequently speeds up prep time.

The sloped design present throughout George Foreman models rids the food of excess oil, and gives you a much healthier final product than a grill could offer.

The addition of the floating hinge gives cooks a way to cook larger sized items, as the user can fully adjust the gap between the two cooking plates.

Aside from its larger grilling capacity, this model separates itself from other George Foreman grills with its heat potential.

It boasts a 5 minute warm-up time, and the plates cook food at such a quick pace, that many customers reportedly burned the first few items they cooked.

Pros

  • Efficient: quick warm-up, and crazy fast cooking
  • Size: incredibly large capacity can handle plenty of food for a family
  • Classic: upholds the George Foreman standard with the classic features
  • Design: floating hinge gives users extra bit of control, allows for wider range of food options

Cons

  • Cleaning: the cooking plates are not removable, so cleaning is a bit more difficult
  • Usability: lack of temperature control, power switch, or timer makes this model a bit too simplistic

Bottom Line

The 9-Serving George Foreman Grill would be a great addition to any kitchen, particularly for large families, or over worked kitchens, where grill space is hard to come by.

Its size, coupled with its heating capacity, make this model one of the most efficient on the market, though not at the expense of the classic Foreman features we have come to expect.

Cleaning is rather difficult in comparison to other models, and the lack of temperature control, a power switch, and a timer, certainly doesn't give this model an edge over its adversaries.

Nonetheless, this product offers a much larger size, and still works just as well as the classic George Foreman models. If you're looking to cook a high volume of food with your grill, the 9-serving grill will be a satisfactory model.

4. Best George Foreman Grill with Removable Plates: George Foreman 5-Serving Grill

The 5-Serving George Foreman Grill offers a unique blend of the 4-Serving and 6-Serving models.

This model accurately captures the iconic Foreman design of the 4-Serving, yet introduces the ceramic surface, present in the 6-Serving model, to its removable grilling plates.

The only true differences between this particular model and the 4-Serving, is the previously mentioned ceramic surface, as well as the slight increase in grilling surface.

This model offers just a bit extra for those cook's looking to get a bit more cooking space, and the assurance that the extra surface is made of the best material that George Foreman has to offer.

Pros

  • Size: slight increase in grilling surface area gives extra room for larger meals
  • Ceramic: the addition of ceramic pushes it above the similar 4-Serving model
  • Classic: this grill doesn't stray from the brand standard; includes the classic George Foreman features

Cons

  • Ceramic: tends to wear away rather quickly; we recommend gentle hand washing only
  • Simplistic: lack of temperature control, floating hinge, on/off switch, or timer is a definite negative

Bottom Line

The 5-Serving George Foreman Grill is another solid model from the brand, though it does little to distinguish itself from the other models.

It is nearly identical to the 4-Serving model, aside from the additional cooking space and its use of ceramic as the grilling plate surface.

Consequently, this grill is just as solid a choice as the classic 4-Serving, perhaps even better due to the larger size and ceramic surface. The distinction between these two models is rather small, and honestly boils down to personal preference and market price.

5. Best George Foreman Indoor Grill: George Foreman 15-Serving Grill

We've truly saved the best, or at least most innovative, George Foreman Grill for last.

The 15-Serving Indoor/Outdoor Electric Grill is a cross between the classic, indoor grill that the Foreman brand is famous for, and an ordinary outdoor grill.

In lieu of the top-bottom heating approach pioneered by its predecessors, this model opts for a more traditional grilling surface.

However, to stay true to the brand, the model employs two angled grilling plates, which brings the classic calorie cutting design of the indoor George Foreman, to the outdoor grill.

Further keeping with the brand standard, the 15-Serving Indoor/Outdoor Grill includes the Foreman Tough non-stick surface used by the indoor models.

A temperature control gauge gives cooks a bit of creative freedom when grilling, offering 5 distinct temperature settings.

While this grill may look like an outdoor exclusive model, its name does not disappoint. With relative ease, the grill stand can be removed, and the grill can be utilized within the confines of your own kitchen.

Pros

  • Size: 15-Servings provides one of the largest cooking surfaces on the market for electric grills
  • Electric: this grill is ideal for apartment living, as the electric design allows it to be safely used on any deck or porch
  • Usability: 5-setting temperature control gauge encourages creativity, and opens up a wider range of meal options
  • Versatile: as the name suggests, this grill can function indoors and out, thanks to its innovative design and removable stand

Cons

  • Cleaning: the grilling plates are not removable, and its awkwardly large profile is not exactly ideal for sink washing
  • Size: the large grilling surface is ideal, but storing this grill might be a bit of a challenge if you don't opt to keep it outdoors

Bottom Line

The 15-Serving Indoor/Outdoor Electric Grill is arguably the best George Foreman model you can find on the market, and it will serve you well.

The ability to work both indoors and out gives this product an edge over its predecessors, as well as any other competitors on the market. 

The innovative mixture of the classic George Foreman design and a traditional outdoor grill gives this grill a winning edge.

The difficult cleaning process, troubling lifespan, and materials are of some concern, but they seem to be fairly ubiquitous aspects of George Foreman Grills. 

Whether you want to grill in the backyard, on the patio, in the kitchen, or at a tailgate, this grill has you covered. All in all, you cannot go wrong with this model if you're in the market for a George Foreman; or any grill for that matter.

Conclusion

George Foreman Grills are some of the most handy appliances you could ever have in your kitchen.

The prospect of additional grilling space is always a positive, but the quick, efficient, calorie cutting design that is synonymous with the Foreman brand gives these grills that extra edge.

Whether you are cooking a meal on the run, or making a full course dinner for your family, these grills will provide you with a quick, healthy alternative to traditional grilling.

 Take your time to thoroughly look through the fine details when comparing models on the market, as some distinctions are rather minuscule.

Ultimately, almost any of the George Foreman models will suffice for an indoor grill, though some models certainly offer more advantages than others.

Regardless, the decision is ultimately up to you, as finding the right George Foreman grill is more about personal preference and cooking needs than fancy features or new models.

Be patient on the market, compare models based on your needs, and rest easy knowing that no matter which model you decide on, you'll have a handy, innovative grill at your disposal.

Leave a Comment